Skip to main content

Alternative measures

Three false myths about prison pt.3: let us debunk commonplaces about detention

6 of 32One topic at a time

We analyse three widespread prejudices about detention, explaining why they are wrong and illustrating the real conditions of detained persons.

Transcript

Since it was very successful, today we are proposing this format again: false myths about prison, part 3.

First false myth: those who serve their sentence outside prison have got away with it. Well, this is a false myth. Alternative measures are not a solution. Those who are on probation with the social service must respect schedules, bans and regular meetings with social workers. Those under home detention can only leave the house with authorisation, those in semi-liberty leave to work or study, but in the evening return to prison. If the rules are violated, the measure can be revoked.

Second false myth: those who enter prison lose all their rights. This is also a false myth. The sentence removes personal freedom, but does not erase other rights. The prison system, for example, establishes that work in prison must not have a punitive character and must be paid. And in 2024 the Constitutional Court, with judgment number 10, recognised the right of detained persons to have intimate visits with their partner without the visual control of an officer.

Third false myth: prison is the same everywhere. This is also a false myth. In reality, where the sentence is served changes a lot. According to the National Guarantor, in April 2026 overcrowding in Puglia exceeded 175%, while in Valle d'Aosta the detained persons were fewer than the available places and the differences also concern opportunity.

There are institutions in which most of the detained persons work, study or attend a course and others in which these possibilities are almost absent.

Same law, very different conditions. Prison is one of the places about which there are more opinions and fewer real facts. Starting from the numbers is the first step to talk about it better.

And you? Did you believe any of these false myths?

What it covers

Laws cited

  • Art. 27 Constitution — Criminal responsibility is personal and the punishment must aim at the re-education of the convicted person.
  • Penitentiary System (Law 354/1975) — It establishes the rights and duties of detained persons, including paid and non-punitive work.
  • Judgment Constitutional Court no. 10/2024 — It recognises the right to intimate visits without visual supervision for detained persons.

Keywords

  • alternative measures
  • prisoners' rights
  • work in prison
  • intimate visits
  • overcrowding
  • regional differences
  • false myths
  • penitentiary system

One topic at a time

Giulia Troncatti

In one minute, Giulia Troncatti explains how prison works and where reality drifts away from the law.
Who is Giulia Troncatti

The right at stake: alternative measures

Probation, home detention and semi-liberty: serving the sentence, or part of it, outside prison.
Go to the right