Skip to main content

Compensation for an overcrowded prison: when you are entitled to it

If you have less than 3 walkable square metres in your cell, the European Court of Human Rights presumes that your detention is inhuman or degrading treatment. This is why you can claim compensation: one day off your sentence for every ten spent in those conditions, or €8 a day if your sentence has already ended or the reduction cannot be fully applied.

Art. 35-ter of the Prison System Act · ECtHR, Torreggiani (2013) and Muršić (2016) judgments

Reality
  • The floor disappears beneath the feet of others.
  • Cells without light.
  • Mold on the walls, freezing water, cockroaches.
Art. 27 — Italian Constitution

Sentences must not consist of treatments contrary to the sense of humanity and must aim at the rehabilitation of the convicted person.

The paradox is that the State, in the act of punishing those who have broken the law, ends up violating its own fundamental law.

The situation in Italy

  • 142.8%

    Real overcrowding rate

    Ottorighe on DAP data · September 2026

  • 3 sq m

    Minimum space per person according to the European Court of Human Rights

    ECtHR, Art. 3 ECHR · Torreggiani (2013) and Muršić (2016) judgments

  • 46.1%

    of the prisons visited in 2025 had cells without hot water

    Antigone Observatory · 102 visits, 2025

The feet of a person standing in a narrow, empty cell.

What the law provides

Living space is dignity

The «sense of humanity» enshrined in the Constitution vanishes when a man or a woman is forced to live in cramped spaces, without enough light, in crumbling buildings and in poor sanitary conditions. Detention cannot be a means of rehabilitation; it is pure physical and mental suffering. In this way, the sentence becomes an unlawful sanction.

Art. 27 of the Constitution: punishments may not consist of treatment contrary to the sense of humanity and must aim at the rehabilitation of the convicted person.

When you're entitled to it, and what you can claim

European case law has drawn a clear line between legitimate punishment and inhuman treatment: living space.

  • How much space am I entitled to?

    At least 3 walkable square meters in a shared cell.

    ECtHR, Torreggiani (2013) and Muršić (2016) judgments

  • What does not count in the calculation?

    Furniture, such as wardrobes or bunk beds. The bathroom area must always be excluded.

    ECtHR, Torreggiani judgment (2013)

  • What can I claim if the space is below the threshold?

    Compensation: below 3 square metres the Court presumes that detention is degrading treatment.

    Article 35-ter of the Prison System Act

  • And if I am still in prison?

    1 day off the sentence still to be served for every 10 days spent in overcrowding conditions.

    Article 35-ter of the Prison System Act

  • And if my remaining sentence is short, or I have already finished serving it?

    The State owes you €8 for every day spent in degrading conditions.

    Article 35-ter of the Prison System Act

  • Who do I apply to for compensation?

    If you are still in prison, to the Supervisory Magistrate. If you have already left, to the court of the district capital where you live, within 6 months of the end of detention.

    Article 35-ter of the Prison System Act

In depth

Further information

The judgment against Italy, and what overcrowding means every day.

In 2013 the European Court of Human Rights found Italy in breach of Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which prohibits inhuman and degrading treatment, because of prison overcrowding. This is the Torreggiani judgment, in which the Court makes clear that prison overcrowding is not bureaucratic mismanagement but a violation of human rights by the State.

In Italy there is a deep gap between what is written on paper and what happens behind bars. The floor disappears under other people's feet. Cells without light. Mould on the walls, freezing water, cockroaches.

If you have lived or are living in these conditions, you can act now.

Create the application with AI right away
Sources (6)The rules and data this page is based on

This page explains how the Italian prison system works; it does not replace a lawyer’s advice.

Discover your other rights