Skip to main content

Compensation for overcrowding

Who is worse off in prison? Not the one who has committed the worst crime, but the one who is poor.

1 of 32One topic at a time

In prison, the worst conditions are experienced by those who are poor and alone, without resources or external help, worsening existing social inequalities.

Transcript

But who is worse off in prison? Not always those who have committed the most serious offence, often those who entered the poorest.

To address this topic we want to start from a concrete case. During a visit with Nessuno toccino we observed that in some sections there was no washing machine. This means that the detained people wash their clothes by hand and hang them wherever they can, in the section or in the detention rooms.

Now winter is coming and there are sweatshirts, tracksuits, heavy trousers to wash and sometimes the water is cold, even though the prison regulations provide for showers with hot water.

Those who have a family nearby solve the problem in this way: they hand over dirty clothes at the visit and receive them clean the next time. Those who are alone, maybe foreign, maybe already homeless before entering, have to manage and sometimes do not even have the money to buy detergent.

Detergent is just one example. In prison almost everything beyond the minimum must be bought: food, coffee, hygiene products, phone calls. The National Guarantor has noted several times that the prices of products sold in the institutions are significantly higher than those on the market, even though the law says they should not be.

Thus the inequalities that exist outside, inside become wider. One might think that it is enough to work.

The problem is that at the end of 2025, 34% of detained people were working, about 21,700 out of 63,500. Two out of three people therefore do not work and those who do almost always work for the prison administration with a salary that Antigone has estimated at around €600 gross per month, from which a part is also withheld for maintenance expenses in prison.

There is then a final paradox. To serve the sentence outside with an alternative measure, you often need a house, a job, someone to take you in. Those who have none of this have less chance of getting out earlier. Prison does not create inequalities, but takes them to the extreme.

So we turn the question to you. If a person has no one outside, no money and cannot manage to work, how do they survive inside a prison? Write it to us in the comments.

What it covers

Laws cited

  • Art. 27 Constitution — Criminal responsibility is personal and punishments must aim at the re-education of the convicted person.
  • Penitentiary System (Law 354/1975), art. 11 and art. 15 — They provide for the right of detained persons to adequate hygienic and sanitary conditions and to treatments that respect dignity.
  • Penitentiary System, art. 9 — It provides the possibility for detained persons to work during detention.

Keywords

  • inequalities
  • living conditions
  • work in prison
  • family
  • poverty
  • basic necessities products
  • alternative measures
  • dignity

One topic at a time

Giulia Troncatti

In one minute, Giulia Troncatti explains how prison works and where reality drifts away from the law.
Who is Giulia Troncatti

The right at stake: compensation for overcrowding

Below 3 m² per person, detention is inhuman. The law provides a shorter sentence or compensation for the days spent in those conditions.
Go to the right