Skip to main content

Compensation for overcrowding

The Italian prison violates the Constitution

The video denounces how Italian prison conditions violate fundamental human rights, hindering rehabilitation and reintegration.

  1. Violations of the laws in prison

    If there is a place where there are more violations of Italian laws, it is prison, but not by the prisoners and by the State.

  2. The role of prison in society

    Does prison, as it works today in Italy, serve to make society safer? Absolutely not. They enter with only a primary school certificate and come out graduated in criminality. Because when you do not make people responsible, as the penitentiary system provides, you infantilise them, so that even to ask for toilet paper you have to make the so-called little request and, eh, where you see, that is, the prisoner sees that the State does not respect the law, so he does not come out re-educated and above all where the hallmark of life in prison is doing nothing, it is having to get creative to do something and often these are not very legal things, in short.

  3. Meaning of prisoners' rights

    First of all, I wanted to ask you what prisoners' rights means and then why you chose to support this project. I always support initiatives that aim to unite, not to divide us, to stimulate debate in order to bring about change. And then I really like prisoners' rights because the law, the real one, the constitutional one, does not exist inside prison. So the rights of prisoners are imprisoned. It is, in my opinion, a brilliant intuition, because we want to bring the law to life, especially the one that refers to human needs that are essential. The UN charter on fundamental human rights and the European convention on human rights is the ABC even for dialogue between states. If there is no agreement on this, what are we talking about? There are fundamental human rights, they are written in this charter, go and read it, that if they are denied we do not belong to human civilisation, but to something different and wrong. The deprivation of liberty is already a punishment and it is the punishment. Everything else is extra, that is, overcrowding is extra. The lack of care is an extra not foreseen because the right to health cannot be denied. The lack of relationships with one's family members, with one's children, is an additional punishment that is not foreseen and is not effective because one day, when the sentence is over, the prisoner will have to return to society. Just think, right? They say animals in captivity. What are animals in captivity like? They are aggressive, as soon as you approach they bite you. If you keep human beings in captivity it is clear that they do not get used to civil coexistence and to human relationships which are an exchange. Man is relationship. If we take relationship away from man we destroy him. And then I like the word movement.

  4. The value of movement and of relationship

    Movement means that you are in relation with others and this is what we must do more and more on difficult issues such as that of deprivation of liberty.

What it covers

Laws cited

  • Art. 27 Constitution — It establishes that criminal responsibility is personal, that the punishment must aim at the rehabilitation of the convicted person, and that punishments contrary to the sense of humanity are not permitted.
  • UN Charter on Fundamental Human Rights — It declares the universal human rights that must be guaranteed to all people, including detainees.
  • European Convention on Human Rights — It protects the rights and fundamental freedoms of individuals, including the right to health and to respect for family life.

Keywords

  • prison
  • human rights
  • rehabilitation
  • overcrowding
  • health
  • report
  • deprivation of liberty
  • movement

The right at stake: compensation for overcrowding

Below 3 m² per person, detention is inhuman. The law provides a shorter sentence or compensation for the days spent in those conditions.
Go to the right