The video denounces the overcrowding and inhuman conditions of Italian prisons, highlighting the illegality of the State and the need for reforms.
The illegality of the State in prisons
The State is in absolute illegality because prisoners now find themselves living worse than pigs in pigsties.
It is called early release in reality because it also provides for a special early release. Basically, what happens?
The overcrowding of Italian prisons
We have prisons which today, as we record, have reached almost detainees present. In reality, the places they say are available, 51,000, are not even 51,000 because in reality they are 46,000, because many cells are under work, restructuring and so on.
So we have an excessive rate of presences compared to what they could be of 140%. Faced with all this, the State is in absolute illegality, because the detainees now find themselves living worse than pigs in pigsties and totally outside the rules imposed by Europe, but also by our Constitution, when it provides that one cannot stay in prisons in inhuman conditions.
Prison outside the law, but it is in absolute illegality both with respect to what Europe provides, I remind that the ECHR has already condemned us about ten years ago, reason for which the first law for special early release was made, but we are under illegality also with respect to our Constitution, because even the Constitution speaks of detainees who cannot live in inhuman and degrading conditions. Not by chance, by now there are thousands and thousands of detainees who are compensated by the surveillance courts, not having money to compensate them, they compensate them exactly with reductions of sentence.
Faced with this explosive situation, I leave aside all the norms that are made and that instead of working to remove people from prison work to put others in. I refer to all the security decrees and so on.
Here, faced with this situation Nessuno tocchi Caino and I have only made myself a bearer in parliament of this bill, made a bill that increases a part of the rewards that already exist thanks to a law called Gozzini for detainees which are 60 days of reward every so many months.
Early release and behaviour in prison
If you behave well in prison, therefore they are conditional on behaviour in prison so that the prisons can gradually reduce this presence. This presence does not only affect the prisoners, it affects the whole prison world, it affects the prison police who are already understaffed on their own and therefore struggle, but it affects the ASL, it affects the operators, it affects the third sector, it affects that vast world that operates inside the prison and that, when you reach these numbers, is paralysed in its functions at any level.
The role and the difficulties of psychologists in prison
Take a psychologist. A psychologist in prison normally, in a normal situation, should follow 10. But if there is 140% overcrowding, that psychologist has to follow 15, 20, 25 and clearly is not able to fulfil a very delicate matter.
Just think of all the new arrivals, of the people, of the young boys who end up in prison, maybe because they have dealt and distributed a few kilos of marijuana, just to say, and who end up in the middle of a situation. The work of the psychologist is fundamental, suicides are also linked to this.
So the law on early release simply says: let us create the conditions, given the state of illegality, so that many people who could leave prison because they have a low residual sentence can do so early because they have behaved well.
Then, on the side of this, it is clear that if we returned to full respect of the Constitution, a third of the detainees are awaiting trial and should not be in prison. Those who are drug addicts should not be in prison, they should be in communities.
The management of prisoners with psychiatric problems
People who have psychiatric problems should not be in... If we implemented the Constitution according to what the articles of our charter prescribe, we and the prisons would be much, much freer than they are at this moment.
Degrading living conditions in prisons
They live in a condition that is certainly less noble than that of pigs in pigsties, because bear in mind that for pigsties the European Union has now made very strict rules so that they must be kept in a certain condition. I am serious, I am not making a joke. For prisoners this does not exist.
Last year I visited the Viterbo prison with my colleague Boschi and I think this gives you the scale of it. Just one situation of this kind is enough to show what our prison system is, where, since there are no longer spaces for detention in the cells, the rooms for the barber, the recreation rooms, other rooms and so on were being used.
And we passed by, at one point there was a prisoner inside a room without windows, without a toilet, who urinated into a plastic bottle, handed the plastic bottle to the prison police officer who emptied it and brought it back to him. How should we judge this? Even if it were only one person and unfortunately it is not only one.
By now, with overcrowding, there are many institutions that use rooms without toilets, we have seen them also at Regina Celi, or without windows to keep prisoners. And how do we want to judge these? Do they live better or worse than pigs in pigsties? There is only one small problem, which is that they may be people who have done even the worst things, but the State has a different function from revenge. The State must implement article 27 to ensure that even those who have made mistakes can be reintegrated into society in better conditions.
A person who lives inside the prison in those conditions, do you think they will ever come out in better conditions?
Conclusions and final reflections
But look, since I don't think this programme can last 3 days, 3 and a half days, for me it is impossible to identify a memory, it is impossible to identify a battle. I could tell you that there are no memories, there are no battles because in life, at least in mine, but I think in many of ours, the memories and the battles of Pannella are the daily life with which we measure ourselves every day.
Even the way in which each of us does politics is very much conditioned, at least as far as I am concerned, by the formation with the radical culture and with the radical political practice that I started at 19 years old and finished only 19 hours ago, there you go, to be clear. So if you ask me at this moment, perhaps at this moment the memory is physical and it is the mind that goes here in front of a headquarters, that is, actually to a house that I have visited many times for interviews with him, for Radio Radicale, to talk, for and so I have a memory, how to say, scented of a street, of a road, of a house that in my life has been particularly.
What it covers
Laws cited
- Art. 27 Constitution — It establishes that punishments must aim at the rehabilitation of the convicted person and prohibits inhuman or degrading treatment.
- ECHR (European Convention on Human Rights) — It prohibits inhuman or degrading treatment and has already condemned Italy for prison overcrowding.
- Gozzini Law (L. 354/1975, art. 54 and following) — It provides for prison benefits such as early release for good behaviour.
- Security decrees — Rules that have increased the number of prisoners instead of reducing it.
Keywords
- prison overcrowding
- inhuman conditions
- early release
- Gozzini law
- article 27 constitution
- echr
- prisoners' rights
- psychologists in prison
Who speaks
Roberto Giachetti



