Skip to main content

Compensation for overcrowding

Giachetti: "Prisons are pigsties, the State is acting unlawfully"

The video denounces the overcrowding and inhuman conditions of Italian prisons, highlighting the illegality of the State and the need for reforms.

  1. The illegality of the State in prisons

    The State is in absolute illegality because prisoners now find themselves living worse than pigs in pigsties.

  2. The overcrowding of Italian prisons

    We have prisons which today, as we record, have reached almost detainees present. In reality, the places they say are available, 51,000, are not even 51,000 because in reality they are 46,000, because many cells are under work, restructuring and so on.

  3. Early release and behaviour in prison

    If you behave well in prison, therefore they are conditional on behaviour in prison so that the prisons can gradually reduce this presence. This presence does not only affect the prisoners, it affects the whole prison world, it affects the prison police who are already understaffed on their own and therefore struggle, but it affects the ASL, it affects the operators, it affects the third sector, it affects that vast world that operates inside the prison and that, when you reach these numbers, is paralysed in its functions at any level.

  4. The role and the difficulties of psychologists in prison

    Take a psychologist. A psychologist in prison normally, in a normal situation, should follow 10. But if there is 140% overcrowding, that psychologist has to follow 15, 20, 25 and clearly is not able to fulfil a very delicate matter.

  5. The management of prisoners with psychiatric problems

    People who have psychiatric problems should not be in... If we implemented the Constitution according to what the articles of our charter prescribe, we and the prisons would be much, much freer than they are at this moment.

  6. Degrading living conditions in prisons

    They live in a condition that is certainly less noble than that of pigs in pigsties, because bear in mind that for pigsties the European Union has now made very strict rules so that they must be kept in a certain condition. I am serious, I am not making a joke. For prisoners this does not exist.

  7. Conclusions and final reflections

    But look, since I don't think this programme can last 3 days, 3 and a half days, for me it is impossible to identify a memory, it is impossible to identify a battle. I could tell you that there are no memories, there are no battles because in life, at least in mine, but I think in many of ours, the memories and the battles of Pannella are the daily life with which we measure ourselves every day.

What it covers

Laws cited

  • Art. 27 Constitution — It establishes that punishments must aim at the rehabilitation of the convicted person and prohibits inhuman or degrading treatment.
  • ECHR (European Convention on Human Rights) — It prohibits inhuman or degrading treatment and has already condemned Italy for prison overcrowding.
  • Gozzini Law (L. 354/1975, art. 54 and following) — It provides for prison benefits such as early release for good behaviour.
  • Security decrees — Rules that have increased the number of prisoners instead of reducing it.

Keywords

  • prison overcrowding
  • inhuman conditions
  • early release
  • Gozzini law
  • article 27 constitution
  • echr
  • prisoners' rights
  • psychologists in prison

Who speaks

Roberto Giachetti

The right at stake: compensation for overcrowding

Below 3 m² per person, detention is inhuman. The law provides a shorter sentence or compensation for the days spent in those conditions.
Go to the right