Alternative measures to prison reduce recidivism and are more effective for minor offences, but they are still applied too little.
Why prison violates the laws
It almost seems as if the Italian State has decided to send to prison all those people who have difficulty living in society.
My first entries into prison I made with Marco Pannella, because he was a member of parliament, I was not. It only happened many years later that I entered Montecitorio as an elected member, but the first visits, which date back decades, I made following Marco Pannella.
I must say, however, that the feeling of entering a place of suffering has remained for all these years. I continue to experience it as a non-place where it is difficult to make those who manage power, those who have the responsibility of managing the penitentiary institutions, understand that they are outside legality.
That is, if there is a place where the law does not prevail, you enter prison. There, it is not the crimes committed by the detainees, but there are the crimes that are committed inside the penitentiary institutions by a State that should respect all the laws starting from the Constitution and the law concerning the penitentiary system.
When one thinks
Why alternative pathways to detention work - and why they are applied little
Or one hears, for example, on television that a person has been convicted, one immediately thinks that they have been sentenced to prison, whereas sentences can be alternative measures to imprisonment, indeed they can be resolved and are much more effective than prison in terms of recidivism, especially for minor offences, it is not recommended to take that step, because that step marks you for life.
Probation exists, but it is rarely applied for those who are in prison. It is applied, above all, for those who are caught in a state of intoxication, those who have road accidents, those who are caught driving, perhaps under the influence of narcotic substances.
And so there are 64,000 prisoners at a given moment, plus there are 140,000 alternative measures, so it is quite an extensive penal area. It would be necessary to ensure that prison, imprisonment is really, as is often said, the extrema ratio, so you go to prison, but 10,000 people with all the prison assets we have and because you are still dangerous for society and then it is good that you undertake a very long path to rethink the offence you have committed and to repair the mistake made.
Hope cannot be denied to anyone. This has also been said by the European Court of Human Rights, the Constitutional Court, for which the 'ergastolo ostativo' has been abolished, with a thousand difficulties, but in any case in Italy we no longer have the 'ergastolo ostativo', that is, life imprisonment without hope.
Who is in prison today? So,
Who is currently in penitentiary institutions: people with addictions, with psychological fragility, in conditions of poverty and social marginalisation
It is really people living in social marginalisation who are found there. It almost seems as if the Italian State has decided to send to prison all those people who have difficulties fitting into society and so we find pathological drug addicts – a great many.
And we also have psychiatric cases in a certain number. We have the poor, those who do not have a home, no longer have meaningful relationships, anyone to take care of them, and then foreigners, especially those without documents, who live on the margins. So all this mass is put inside prison.
Then, of course, there are those belonging to organised crime, there are other offences, but the majority is made up of these people when, if we think about it, it would be much more important to do prevention. For example, psychiatric cases have increased not only because of the abuse of drugs, because often these people have a dual diagnosis, but they have increased since State resources for proximity services have been removed.
So, whereas before, up to 10-15 years ago, 20 years ago, cases of psychiatric distress were intercepted, today they are not, they are only intercepted at the moment when perhaps a crime is committed and instead prevention is needed and often families are not helped in this.
What it covers
Laws cited
- Art. 27 Constitution — It establishes that punishments must aim at the rehabilitation of the convicted person and prohibits treatments contrary to the sense of humanity.
- Law on the Penitentiary System (L. 354/1975) — It regulates the functioning of prisons and provides for alternative measures to detention.
- European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) — It has established that the sentence must leave a hope of reintegration, prohibiting sentences without the prospect of release.
- Constitutional Court, ruling on the 'ergastolo ostativo' (life imprisonment without parole) — It declared the 'ergastolo ostativo' unconstitutional, that is, the sentence without the possibility of benefits or hope of release.
Keywords
- prison
- alternative measures
- irreducible life sentence
- recidivism
- social marginalisation
- dependencies
- human rights
- prevention
Who speaks
Rita Bernardini
The right at stake: alternative measures
More videos on this right

Doing Business in Dozza: Prison Work That Cuts Recidivism
Valerio Monteventi



