Skip to main content

Alternative measures

Alternative paths to detention - Here is why they work

Alternative measures to prison reduce recidivism and are more effective for minor offences, but they are still applied too little.

  1. Why prison violates the laws

    It almost seems as if the Italian State has decided to send to prison all those people who have difficulty living in society.

  2. Why alternative pathways to detention work - and why they are applied little

    Or one hears, for example, on television that a person has been convicted, one immediately thinks that they have been sentenced to prison, whereas sentences can be alternative measures to imprisonment, indeed they can be resolved and are much more effective than prison in terms of recidivism, especially for minor offences, it is not recommended to take that step, because that step marks you for life.

  3. Who is currently in penitentiary institutions: people with addictions, with psychological fragility, in conditions of poverty and social marginalisation

    It is really people living in social marginalisation who are found there. It almost seems as if the Italian State has decided to send to prison all those people who have difficulties fitting into society and so we find pathological drug addicts – a great many.

What it covers

Laws cited

  • Art. 27 Constitution — It establishes that punishments must aim at the rehabilitation of the convicted person and prohibits treatments contrary to the sense of humanity.
  • Law on the Penitentiary System (L. 354/1975) — It regulates the functioning of prisons and provides for alternative measures to detention.
  • European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) — It has established that the sentence must leave a hope of reintegration, prohibiting sentences without the prospect of release.
  • Constitutional Court, ruling on the 'ergastolo ostativo' (life imprisonment without parole) — It declared the 'ergastolo ostativo' unconstitutional, that is, the sentence without the possibility of benefits or hope of release.

Keywords

  • prison
  • alternative measures
  • irreducible life sentence
  • recidivism
  • social marginalisation
  • dependencies
  • human rights
  • prevention

The right at stake: alternative measures

Probation, home detention and semi-liberty: serving the sentence, or part of it, outside prison.
Go to the right