Skip to main content

Glossary · Who decides and how to ask

Supervisory judge

In brief

The judge who, after the conviction, decides how the sentence is carried out and whether the rights of the person serving it are respected.

Written by the team of the Italian Movement for Prisoners' Rights (Movimento Italiano Diritti Detenuti)

Description

Created with the Prison Act of 1975 (Law 354/1975), the supervisory judge is the judge of the enforcement of the sentence. They do not decide whether a person is guilty: that has already been established. They decide how that sentence is carried out and whether the rights of the person serving it are respected. In practice, the supervisory judge visits prisons, listens to the people inside who ask to speak with them, and decides on complaints (art. 35-bis), reward permits, early release (the 45 days off the sentence for each six months granted to those who took part in the rehabilitation programme) and the compensation due when detention took place in conditions contrary to the sense of humanity (art. 35-ter). They also oversee how prisons are organised.

The decisions that matter most for liberty (probation, semi-liberty, home detention, parole) are instead taken by the supervisory court, a panel in which two experts such as psychologists, criminologists or educationalists sit beside the judges.

Why is it important to know this figure? Because in Italy the sentence is not a purely administrative matter: it is subject to a judge's control. For a person in prison, the supervisory judge is often the only channel to enforce a right that has been denied: a cell that is too small, treatment that never arrived, a transfer hundreds of kilometres away from the family. But this control works only if it has the resources to work. Understaffed supervisory offices and heavy workloads mean long delays. And a right recognised when the sentence has already ended is a right emptied of meaning.

Sources (3)The rules and data this page is based on

Listen, watch, read, understand. Four ways into prison without having been there.

In this section